Real Estate Insights

My 1031 Exchange: From a Provo Duplex to a St. George Short-Term Rental

By Joshua Sterling, REALTOR®, RE/MAX Associates ·

In 2020, I sold a duplex in Provo and used a 1031 exchange to buy an investment property at Las Palmas Resort in St. George that I now run as a short-term rental. The duplex was producing about $150 a month after all expenses. The St. George property has averaged roughly $1,200 to $1,600 a month over the last 12 months, also after all expenses, including the mortgage. The hardest part was lining up the two closings inside the exchange deadlines.

Las Palmas Resort in St. George, Utah, where Joshua's replacement property is located

I talk with investors about 1031 exchanges all the time, but this one is personal. In 2020, I sold a duplex in Provo and used a 1031 exchange to buy an investment property at Las Palmas Resort in St. George that I now operate as a short-term rental. Here's what I did, why I did it, and what I'd want any Utah investor to know before starting an exchange.

Why did I sell my Provo duplex?

My Provo duplex was producing only about $150 a month after all expenses. I wanted my equity working harder, with better cash flow and room for long-term growth.

Joshua's former duplex in Provo, Utah
The Provo duplex I sold.

How did a 1031 exchange fit?

A 1031 exchange lets an investor sell real property held for investment and buy like-kind replacement property while potentially deferring eligible capital gains taxes. Two rules shape every exchange: the sale proceeds go to a qualified intermediary instead of to you, and the deadlines start the day your sale closes.

  • Day 45: identify your replacement property in writing.
  • Day 180: close on the replacement property, or by your tax return due date (including extensions) if that comes first.

Weekends and holidays don't extend either deadline. You can see your own dates with my free 1031 deadline calculator.

The hardest part for me was coordinating the two closings so the sale and the purchase lined up inside the exchange deadlines.

Why did I choose St. George?

St. George offered much better cash-flow potential as a short-term rental, strong growth, and it was a market I already knew well.

Las Palmas Resort Condominiums entrance sign in St. George, Utah
Las Palmas Resort in St. George.

What changed after the exchange?

Both figures are my own approximate monthly cash flow after all expenses, including the mortgage.
Provo duplex (sold)St. George rental (purchased)
TypeLong-term rental duplexShort-term rental at Las Palmas Resort
Monthly cash flowAbout $150About $1,200 to $1,600 (12-month average)

I manage the St. George property with a mix of my own work and outside help, and it takes more effort than a long-term rental. Short-term rental income varies with season, occupancy, management and expenses.

A note on short-term rentals and 1031 exchanges

Short-term rentals can raise extra questions in an exchange, especially about how the property is used and how much personal use it has. Not every vacation property qualifies. If you're considering a short-term rental as replacement property, talk with your qualified intermediary and tax adviser about your plans before you buy.

What would I tell an investor starting a 1031 exchange today?

  1. Work with an experienced team. Your agent, qualified intermediary and tax adviser should all have done exchanges before, because the deadlines don't leave room to learn on the fly.
  2. Line up your qualified intermediary before your sale closes. Once the sale closes without one, it's too late.
  3. Start looking before day 1. Have realistic replacement options in mind before your sale closes, not after.
  4. Name a backup or two. When you identify properties, include alternatives in case your first choice falls through.

How can I help with your 1031 exchange?

I help investors with the real estate side of an exchange: selling the property you're leaving, finding and negotiating the one you're buying, and keeping the deadlines in front of everyone. Selling an investment property? Buying replacement property? Or start with my complete Utah 1031 exchange guide and the investor hub.

Frequently asked questions

Can you do a 1031 exchange into a short-term rental?
Sometimes. A short-term rental can be like-kind replacement property when it's held for investment, but how you use and operate it matters, including any personal use. Confirm your plans with your qualified intermediary and tax adviser before you buy.
How long do you have to find a replacement property in a 1031 exchange?
You have 45 days from the day your sale closes to identify replacement property in writing, and 180 days to close, or until your tax return due date (including extensions) if that comes first. Weekends and holidays don't extend either deadline.
Do I need a qualified intermediary for a 1031 exchange?
For a standard delayed exchange, yes. The sale proceeds must go to a qualified intermediary rather than to you. Set one up before your sale closes.
Can I exchange a Provo property for one in St. George or elsewhere in Utah?
Yes. Real property held for investment in the United States is generally like-kind to other U.S. investment real property, so a rental in one Utah city can be exchanged for one in another city or state. Your qualified intermediary and tax adviser confirm the details for your situation.
Joshua Sterling, REALTOR® with RE/MAX Associates

About the author

Joshua Sterling

REALTOR® | RE/MAX Associates | Utah License #11833167-SA00

Joshua has helped more than 200 Utah families buy and sell homes over the past six years and ranks among the Top 1% of Realtors in the state. He moved to Utah in 2013 to attend BYU, lives in Utah County with his wife and four daughters, and owns and invests in rental properties.

Hablo español: Joshua works with clients in English and Spanish.

More about Joshua

Thinking about a 1031 exchange in Utah?

Whether you're selling an investment property or buying replacement property, I'm glad to share what I've learned as both an agent and an investor. Reach out anytime.

Joshua Sterling, REALTOR® | RE/MAX Associates

(385) 204-5596 · joshuasterlingre@gmail.com

365 S Garden Grove Ln Ste 110, Pleasant Grove, UT 84062

Utah License #11833167-SA00

Joshua Sterling is a REALTOR® with RE/MAX Associates. He handles the real estate side of your exchange and is not a CPA, attorney, investment adviser or qualified intermediary. Confirm exchange eligibility, deadlines and tax treatment with your qualified intermediary and tax adviser. Joshua's experience is shared for illustration only. Results vary, and past results don't predict future ones.