How to Find and Buy 1031 Replacement Property in Utah
By Joshua Sterling, REALTOR®, RE/MAX Associates ·
Start looking for your 1031 exchange replacement property before your current property closes, because the IRS gives you only 45 days from that sale to identify replacements in writing and 180 days to close. In Utah, common options include single-family rentals, duplexes and fourplexes, small multifamily, land and commercial property, with a Delaware Statutory Trust (DST) sometimes listed as a backup. To potentially defer eligible capital gains taxes, you generally need to buy equal or greater value, reinvest all the net proceeds and replace any debt you paid off. Your qualified intermediary (QI) and tax adviser confirm the exact numbers for your exchange.
When should I start looking for 1031 replacement property?
Start before your sale closes, ideally before you list. The clock starts on the day your relinquished (sold) property transfers. Under the Treasury regulations, the identification period ends at midnight on day 45, and the exchange period ends on day 180 or on your tax return due date (including extensions), whichever comes first (26 CFR §1.1031(k)-1(b)(2)). Weekends and holidays count.
Starting early lets you see what is actually for sale in your price range, get pre-approved, and tour and run rent numbers before you are under deadline pressure.
Want to see your exact dates? Plug your expected closing date into the 1031 exchange deadline calculator. For a deeper look at the timeline, read the 45-day and 180-day rules for Utah exchanges.
How do I set criteria for a replacement property?
Write your criteria down before you tour, so you are not grabbing whatever is available on day 40:
- Price range: what you need to spend to meet the value test (your QI and CPA can estimate it)
- Debt: how much mortgage you are paying off, and how you will replace it
- Management: hands-on, light-touch or close to passive
- Location and property type: drivable or remote; residential, land or commercial
- Hold period: how long you plan to own, and whether you might exchange again
If you are still on the selling side of the exchange, start with the complete guide to selling investment property through a 1031 exchange in Utah.
Does the replacement have to be the same type of property?
No. The IRS explains that real property held for business or investment is generally like-kind to other such real property, and that real property in the United States is not like-kind to property outside the United States (IRS: Like-Kind Exchanges, Real Estate Tax Tips). Since 2018, only real property qualifies.
So you could sell a duplex and buy land, or sell land and buy a small retail building. The same rule lets you exchange into Utah from another state; see buying Utah investment property through a 1031 exchange from another state.
What types of 1031 exchange properties for sale in Utah should I consider?
Each type has trade-offs; this is not a recommendation for any of them.
Single-family rental
- What it typically involves:
- One tenant, familiar financing, broad resale market
- Points to weigh:
- One vacancy means zero rent; HOA rental restrictions in some communities
Duplex / fourplex (2–4 units)
- What it typically involves:
- Multiple rents under one roof; residential-style financing is often available
- Points to weigh:
- Fewer of these listed than single-family; more tenant management
Small multifamily (5+ units)
- What it typically involves:
- More units, commercial-style financing and underwriting
- Points to weigh:
- Larger price points; lender review of rent rolls takes time
Land
- What it typically involves:
- Little or no management; may suit a longer hold
- Points to weigh:
- Usually no rental income; financing can be limited; zoning and utilities matter
Commercial (retail, office, flex, industrial)
- What it typically involves:
- Leases can run longer; tenants may pay some expenses
- Points to weigh:
- Tenant credit and lease terms drive value; more specialized due diligence
DST (Delaware Statutory Trust) interest
- What it typically involves:
- Fractional, passive ownership offered by a sponsor
- Points to weigh:
- Investor gives up control; generally illiquid; offered as a security, so review with a licensed adviser
| Property type | What it typically involves | Points to weigh |
|---|---|---|
| Single-family rental | One tenant, familiar financing, broad resale market | One vacancy means zero rent; HOA rental restrictions in some communities |
| Duplex / fourplex (2–4 units) | Multiple rents under one roof; residential-style financing is often available | Fewer of these listed than single-family; more tenant management |
| Small multifamily (5+ units) | More units, commercial-style financing and underwriting | Larger price points; lender review of rent rolls takes time |
| Land | Little or no management; may suit a longer hold | Usually no rental income; financing can be limited; zoning and utilities matter |
| Commercial (retail, office, flex, industrial) | Leases can run longer; tenants may pay some expenses | Tenant credit and lease terms drive value; more specialized due diligence |
| DST (Delaware Statutory Trust) interest | Fractional, passive ownership offered by a sponsor | Investor gives up control; generally illiquid; offered as a security, so review with a licensed adviser |
Joshua handles the real estate side (residential, land and commercial) and does not sell DST interests. Some investors list a DST as a backup identification; the IRS addressed DSTs in Rev. Rul. 2004-86. Ask your QI and a licensed investment adviser before considering one.
Where are Utah investors buying in 2026?
People often search for the "best places to invest in Utah rental property." There is no single best place; it depends on your price range, rent expectations and management style. Here is Q2 2026 Salt Lake Board of Realtors data, as reported by the Standard-Examiner:
Salt Lake County
- Median single-family price (Q2 2026):
- $645,000 (record high)
- Change vs. Q2 2025:
- +4.88%
- Median condo/townhome:
- $417,900
Utah County
- Median single-family price (Q2 2026):
- $600,000
- Change vs. Q2 2025:
- −0.83%
- Median condo/townhome:
- $399,990
Davis County
- Median single-family price (Q2 2026):
- $568,450
- Change vs. Q2 2025:
- −1.57%
- Median condo/townhome:
- $416,000
Weber County
- Median single-family price (Q2 2026):
- $499,000
- Change vs. Q2 2025:
- +3.11%
- Median condo/townhome:
- $358,000
Tooele County
- Median single-family price (Q2 2026):
- $487,495
- Change vs. Q2 2025:
- −1.52%
- Median condo/townhome:
- $370,950
| County | Median single-family price (Q2 2026) | Change vs. Q2 2025 | Median condo/townhome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Salt Lake County | $645,000 (record high) | +4.88% | $417,900 |
| Utah County | $600,000 | −0.83% | $399,990 |
| Davis County | $568,450 | −1.57% | $416,000 |
| Weber County | $499,000 | +3.11% | $358,000 |
| Tooele County | $487,495 | −1.52% | $370,950 |
- Utah County (Provo, Orem, Lehi, American Fork, Saratoga Springs, Spanish Fork): median slightly below Salt Lake County and down slightly year over year. If you are searching for Utah County investment property for sale, check city and HOA rental rules early.
- Salt Lake County: the highest median of these counties, at a record high.
- Surrounding markets (Tooele, Davis, Weber and others): lower single-family medians, so a given amount of exchange proceeds may cover more property. Rents, vacancy and drive time still need checking property by property.
Past price changes do not predict future values, and nothing here forecasts appreciation or rental returns.
How many replacement properties can I identify?
You have three identification options under 26 CFR §1.1031(k)-1(c)(4):
- 3-property rule: identify up to three properties of any value.
- 200% rule: identify any number of properties, as long as their total fair market value is no more than 200% of the value of what you sold.
- 95% rule: identify more than that, but then you must actually acquire at least 95% of the total value you identified.
The 3-property rule is the simplest; the 95% rule leaves little room for error.
What does a 1031 identification letter look like?
There is no single IRS form. Your identification must be in writing, signed by you, delivered by midnight on day 45 to a party such as your QI, and must describe each property unambiguously, for example by street address or legal description (IRS Form 8824 instructions; 26 CFR §1.1031(k)-1(c)). Many QIs provide their own identification form. You can revoke and replace identifications in writing until day 45.
What should a backup identification list look like?
A backup protects you if your first choice fails inspection, appraisal or financing. Common approaches:
- Primary plus two backups under the 3-property rule, ideally ones you have toured and analyzed
- A backup in a different category, such as a single-family home behind a fourplex
- A DST interest as a backup, reviewed with a licensed adviser
A backup only helps if you could actually close on it.
Can I buy more than one property with one sale's proceeds?
Yes. A 1031 exchange into multiple properties is allowed, such as one larger rental into two smaller ones. Keep in mind:
- More than three properties means using the 200% or 95% rule.
- Every purchase must close within the same 180-day exchange period.
- Combined value and combined debt are what count for boot purposes.
- Each purchase brings its own inspections, appraisal and loan file, so plan the sequence with your lender and QI.
How do I replace value and debt so I don't receive boot?
"Boot" is anything you receive in the exchange that is not like-kind property, such as leftover cash or a reduction in debt. The IRS says boot is taxable to the extent of gain (IRS Real Estate Tax Tips).
To potentially defer eligible capital gains taxes in full, exchangers generally aim to:
- Buy equal or greater value than the net sale price
- Reinvest all net equity the QI holds
- Replace the debt with equal or greater new debt, or added outside cash
Illustration only: sell a duplex for $700,000 and pay off a $250,000 mortgage. To minimize boot, you would typically buy at least $700,000 of property, use all the exchange equity, and replace the $250,000 with new debt or cash. Your QI and CPA should run your actual figures.
How do I get financing ready for a 1031 purchase?
A loan delay can push you past your deadline, so prepare before your sale closes:
- Get a written pre-approval for the property type you want. Loans for one to four units and for five or more units are underwritten differently.
- Tell the lender it is a 1031 exchange, since your down payment comes from the QI.
- Ask about appraisal and underwriting timelines, especially for multifamily or commercial loans.
Joshua refers clients to lenders rather than providing financing himself.
How do I close within 180 days?
Treat day 180 as the outer limit, not the target. The period ends earlier if your tax return comes due first, unless you extend it (Form 8824 instructions).
A workable sequence:
- Days 1–15: tour, analyze, and make offers on your top choices.
- By day 45: deliver your signed identification to the QI.
- Days 45–75: inspections, appraisal, title review and loan underwriting.
- Days 75–120: close, leaving a buffer for delays.
- Days 120–180: reserve for problems, such as a backup purchase if your first choice fails.
Write contract deadlines that fit inside your exchange window, and confirm the QI is ready to wire funds on closing day.
Can I 1031 into a short-term rental or vacation property?
Possibly, but proceed carefully. A property used mainly for personal enjoyment is not held for investment. The IRS created a safe harbor in Rev. Proc. 2008-16 for a dwelling unit that, for a replacement property:
- Is owned for at least 24 months immediately after the exchange
- In each of the two 12-month periods, is rented to another person at fair rental for 14 days or more
- In each of those periods, has personal use that does not exceed the greater of 14 days or 10% of the days it is rented at fair rental
The safe harbor is not the only path, but it gives clear guidelines. Check city and HOA short-term rental rules before you identify.
In 2020 Joshua sold a duplex in Provo through a 1031 exchange and bought an investment property in St. George that he runs as a short-term rental. The hardest part was coordinating the two closings; his tip is to work with an experienced team. Read his Provo duplex to St. George rental case study.
Can I buy before I sell, or use exchange money for improvements?
Sometimes, with special structures:
- Reverse exchange: you acquire the replacement before selling, usually through an exchange accommodation titleholder under Rev. Proc. 2000-37, which is referenced in the Form 8824 instructions.
- Improvement (build-to-suit) exchange: exchange funds pay for improvements, generally completed within the 180-day period, using a similar arrangement.
Both add cost and complexity, so talk to your QI first.
Serving Utah and Salt Lake Counties, plus surrounding Utah markets. See all investor resources or the Utah 1031 exchange overview.
Sources
- IRS, "Like-Kind Exchanges – Real Estate Tax Tips"
- IRS, Instructions for Form 8824
- 26 CFR §1.1031(k)-1 (Cornell LII) · official eCFR
- IRS, Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-10 (Rev. Proc. 2008-16)
- First American Exchange, summary of Rev. Proc. 2008-16
- IRS, Internal Revenue Bulletin 2004-33 (Rev. Rul. 2004-86)
- Standard-Examiner, "Home prices break record in Salt Lake but dip slightly in other counties" (July 21, 2026; Salt Lake Board of Realtors data)
Frequently asked questions
- How do I find 1031 exchange replacement property in Utah?
- Set written criteria, get pre-approved, and start searching before your current property closes. A local agent can run MLS searches, check rents and rental rules, and help line up backups so you can identify properties within 45 days.
- How many properties can I identify in a 1031 exchange?
- Up to three of any value (3-property rule); any number with a combined value of no more than 200% of the sold property (200% rule); or more than that if you acquire at least 95% of the identified value (95% rule), per 26 CFR §1.1031(k)-1(c)(4).
- Can I buy a replacement property in a different state?
- Yes. U.S. real property held for investment or business use is generally like-kind to other U.S. real property held the same way. Your home state may have its own filing requirements.
- Do I have to buy a more expensive property?
- To potentially defer all eligible gain, exchangers generally buy property of equal or greater value, reinvest all net proceeds and replace any debt paid off. Buying for less is allowed, but the difference may be taxable boot.
- Can I 1031 exchange into land or commercial property in Utah?
- Yes, if you hold it for investment or business use. Land usually produces little income, and commercial property calls for lease and tenant review.
- Can a DST be my replacement property?
- A DST interest has been treated as real property for 1031 purposes under Rev. Rul. 2004-86, and some investors list one as a backup. DSTs are passive, generally illiquid and offered as securities, so review them with a licensed investment adviser and your QI.
- What happens if I can't close within 180 days?
- Property received after the exchange period generally does not qualify, and the exchange may fail, making the gain taxable. Ask your QI and CPA about your situation.

About the author
Joshua Sterling
REALTOR® | RE/MAX Associates | Utah License #11833167-SA00
Joshua has helped more than 200 Utah families buy and sell homes over the past six years and ranks among the Top 1% of Realtors in the state. He moved to Utah in 2013 to attend BYU, lives in Utah County with his wife and four daughters, and owns and invests in rental properties.
Hablo español: Joshua works with clients in English and Spanish.
More about JoshuaQuestions about a 1031 exchange in Utah?
I help investors with the real estate side of an exchange, alongside your qualified intermediary and tax adviser. Reach out anytime.
Joshua Sterling, REALTOR® | RE/MAX Associates
(385) 204-5596 · joshuasterlingre@gmail.com
365 S Garden Grove Ln Ste 110, Pleasant Grove, UT 84062
Utah License #11833167-SA00
Joshua Sterling is a REALTOR® with RE/MAX Associates. He handles the real estate side of your exchange and is not a CPA, attorney, investment adviser or qualified intermediary. Confirm exchange eligibility, deadlines and tax treatment with your qualified intermediary and tax adviser.
