Can You Do a 1031 Exchange Into a Park City or Heber Vacation Home?
By Joshua Sterling, REALTOR®, RE/MAX Associates ·
Possibly. A vacation home only qualifies for a 1031 exchange if it is held for investment, and the IRS offers a safe harbor in Rev. Proc. 2008-16 that spells out what that looks like: own it for 24 months, rent it at fair rent for at least 14 days in each 12-month period, and keep personal use within set limits. A home you mainly use yourself generally won't qualify.
Why is a vacation home tricky in a 1031?
A 1031 exchange is for real property held for investment or business use. A second home sits in a gray area: you may rent it out, but you also enjoy it. Rev. Proc. 2008-16 gives a safe harbor. If you meet it, the IRS won't challenge whether the home counts as investment property. If you don't, the home could still qualify based on all the facts, but you lose that certainty.
What does the safe harbor require?
For a replacement property (a vacation home you buy in the exchange), the home must be:
- Owned for at least 24 months immediately after the exchange.
- Rented at fair rent for 14 days or more in each of the two 12-month periods.
- Used personally no more than the greater of 14 days or 10% of the days it was rented at fair rent in each of those 12-month periods.
The same tests apply to a vacation home you're selling as the relinquished property, measured over the 24 months before the exchange.
Example: if you rent a Heber cabin at fair rent for 120 days in a year, your personal-use limit that year is 14 days (since 10% of 120 is 12, and 14 is greater). Rent it 200 days and the limit is 20. Personal use can include days used by family members, so confirm the definition with your CPA and keep a calendar.
What should you know about Park City and Heber specifically?
Park City sits in Summit County and Heber City in Wasatch County, both popular resort markets about an hour from the Wasatch Front. That demand is why investors look there, and also why local rules matter. Cities and counties regulate short-term rentals in different ways, including licensing, zoning and HOA restrictions, and rules can differ even between neighborhoods.
Before you identify a property, confirm with the city or county and the HOA whether nightly or short-term rental is allowed at that address. If a property can't legally be rented the way you planned, meeting the fair-rent test gets much harder. Your 45-day identification window is short, so this check should happen early. See the 45-day and 180-day rules.
How do you keep records that support investment use?
- A rental calendar showing paid days and personal days
- Rent rates compared with similar local rentals, to show fair rent
- Leases or booking-platform statements
- Expense records and your business license, if one is required
I've been on the investor side of this too. In 2020 I sold a duplex in Provo through a 1031 exchange and bought an investment property in St. George that I run as a short-term rental. You can read that story here.
Related reading: Finding replacement property · How a Utah 1031 works · Investor resources
Sources
- IRS, Internal Revenue Bulletin 2008-10 (Rev. Proc. 2008-16)
- First American Exchange, IRS Revenue Procedure 2008-16
- IRS, Like-kind exchanges, real estate tax tips
- 26 CFR §1.1031(k)-1
Frequently asked questions
- Can I convert the vacation home to my primary residence later?
- Special rules apply when exchanged property later becomes a residence. Ask your CPA before making plans.
- Does the safe harbor apply to a primary residence?
- No. It's for dwelling units held for investment, such as a vacation rental.
- Do I have to use a property manager?
- No, but you do need to rent at fair market rent and keep records.
- Can I 1031 out of a Park City home into a rental elsewhere?
- Yes, if the Park City home qualifies as investment property.

About the author
Joshua Sterling
REALTOR® | RE/MAX Associates | Utah License #11833167-SA00
Joshua has helped more than 200 Utah families buy and sell homes over the past six years and ranks among the Top 1% of Realtors in the state. He moved to Utah in 2013 to attend BYU, lives in Utah County with his wife and four daughters, and owns and invests in rental properties.
Hablo español: Joshua works with clients in English and Spanish.
More about JoshuaQuestions about a 1031 exchange in Utah?
I help investors with the real estate side of an exchange, alongside your qualified intermediary and tax adviser. Reach out anytime.
Joshua Sterling, REALTOR® | RE/MAX Associates
(385) 204-5596 · joshuasterlingre@gmail.com
365 S Garden Grove Ln Ste 110, Pleasant Grove, UT 84062
Utah License #11833167-SA00
Joshua Sterling is a REALTOR® with RE/MAX Associates. He handles the real estate side of your exchange and is not a CPA, attorney, investment adviser or qualified intermediary. Confirm exchange eligibility, deadlines and tax treatment with your qualified intermediary and tax adviser.
